What If Your Consultant Is Answering the Wrong Question?

Paolo Campillo • November 20, 2026

Issue 16 | November 2026

A periodic publication by 3AM Consultancy.

Recently, we were engaged to help develop a luxury hotel and prepare it for opening.

The owner enjoyed staying in five-star hotels and wanted to build one himself. Fair enough. There is nothing wrong with that ambition, provided the investment makes sense.

Our assignment covered technical services, operating manuals, pre-opening preparations and project coordination. It was a substantial engagement, with plenty of work ahead.

On day one, we asked for the feasibility study.

We were told it had been prepared and would be sent to us. We followed up several times. A year later, we still had not received it.

In the meantime, we had concerns about the hotel's projected performance. The owner was benchmarking the development against established luxury hotels with very different sources of demand. Those properties had advantages that the proposed hotel would not enjoy, yet the projections assumed comparable room rates and occupancy.

We questioned those assumptions and ran some simple calculations.

About three months into the engagement, the owner accepted that the original five-star-plus concept needed reconsideration. We began exploring a four-star alternative, including value engineering the fit-out and reducing specifications. We were close to appointing a specialist consultant to undertake that exercise.

It was a sensible direction to explore. But a less expensive hotel is not necessarily a commercially viable one.

Meanwhile, our contracted work continued. Over approximately a year, we completed the operating manuals and technical services and continued visiting the site. As time passed, however, there was increasingly little progress to see.

Eventually, the owner decided to prioritise another part of the development and put the hotel on hold.

I cannot say whether the hotel would have succeeded had he proceeded. Perhaps it would have. Nor can I say precisely what led to his decision. What I do know is that we had questioned the commercial assumptions from the beginning, and after a year we still had not seen the feasibility study that was supposed to support the investment.

The interesting part is that we were not hired to determine whether the hotel should be built. We were hired to help develop it and prepare it for opening.

We could have confined ourselves to the work in our agreement. There were manuals to complete, technical matters to address and meetings to attend. All legitimate work, and all work that needed doing.

Sunlight throws a grid of shadows across the dirt floor of an unfinished building shell, with steel studs and timber joists opening onto open land beyond.
Illustrative image. Photo: Pexels

But I have spent much of my career operating hotels, including properties designed and developed by other people. You learn what works on paper and what becomes an expensive problem once the hotel opens.

An awkward layout might require additional staff on every shift. A saving during construction might create years of maintenance costs. These things are easy to overlook when everyone is concentrating on getting the building completed.

An owner might engage 3AM for technical services or pre-opening work, but that is not the limit of the experience we bring to the assignment. We have worked across hotel development, operations, pre-opening and asset management, and those disciplines are closely connected.

A design decision affects staffing. Staffing affects operating costs. Operating costs affect returns. I have spent enough years running hotels to know that what looks like a small decision during development can become a recurring expense once the property opens.

We do not pretend to replace every specialist, and we do not undertake work outside an agreed scope without discussing it with the owner. But if we recognise a problem elsewhere in the project, we will raise it. I would find it difficult to justify keeping quiet simply because the concern falls outside the particular service we were engaged to provide.

There is also the question of incentives.

The owner wanted to build a hotel. We had been engaged to help him deliver it. Other consultants had their own assignments. Everyone had work to do, and the project proceeding would generally mean more work for those involved, including us.

There is nothing necessarily wrong with any of that. But it is worth recognising how easily a project can gather momentum before anyone has properly challenged the assumptions behind it.

In our case, we had already moved from a five-star-plus concept towards a four-star alternative. We were looking at ways to reduce the development cost, which was sensible enough. But making a hotel cheaper to build does not necessarily make it worth building.

Consultancy fees matter, and there are excellent specialists who may be exactly right for a particular assignment. But when comparing proposals, I would look beyond the list of deliverables. I would want to know who is doing the work, what experience they bring, and whether they are prepared to question something that does not make sense, even when it falls outside their immediate assignment.

We spent a year helping an owner prepare a hotel for opening while repeatedly asking for the study that was supposed to justify building it. In the end, the hotel was deferred.

Making it cheaper to build was worth exploring. Whether it was worth building remained the more important question.

About the Author

Paolo Campillo is Managing Partner of 3AM Hospitality Consulting, providing independent owner-side advisory for hotels, resorts and mixed-use developments.

Drawing on more than 30 years of operating experience across Asia, he helps owners create and improve hospitality assets that work operationally, commercially and over time.

www.3am.com.ph

Sign Up for Blog Updates

Shaded outdoor hotel entrance with people walking and a valet cart near potted plants
By Paolo Campillo • November 11, 2026
Online travel agencies reshaped hotel distribution while the industry watched. Paolo Campillo asks whether independent hotels can afford to wait as AI travel agents emerge, and how owners could test them carefully.
An empty hotel lobby with low sun streaming through glass doors and long shadows across the floor.
By Paolo Campillo • November 9, 2026
Ritz-Carlton's famous $2,000 rule was never about the money. Paolo Campillo on trusting hotel associates to use their judgment, and the hidden cost of hesitation.
Sunlit arcade with arched openings and arch-shaped patches of light across the floor
By Paolo Campillo • October 30, 2026
A hotel opened with hundreds of rooms on sale and many unfinished. Paolo Campillo on why owners should hear bad news first, and how lost trust was rebuilt.